§01 · Paper case study · computed live by the engines
12 MW green-hydrogen plant, Québec 2026
12 MW electrical input, CF 0.90 (7 884 h/y), €50/MWh contracted electricity, 40 g CO₂/kWh, WACC 8 %, 25 years. 60 % of the output is stored in a 350 bar tank, 30 % trucked over 1 200 km, 10 % piped over 100 km; hydrogen sells at €6.38/kg. Every figure below is produced at page load by the same engine chain the workspace uses, and compared with the value published in the paper.
§02
Reproduction of the published results
Live engine value vs the value printed in the paper. Differences are rounding only.
| Quantity | PEM engine / paper | AEL engine / paper | SOEC engine / paper |
|---|---|---|---|
| Installed CAPEX [M€] | 18.50 / 18.50 ✓ | 12.31 / 12.31 ✓ | 38.89 / 38.89 ✓ |
| OPEX year 1 [M€/y] | 5.51 / 5.51 ✓ | 5.36 / 5.36 ✓ | 6.02 / 6.02 ✓ |
| Output year 1 [t H₂/y] | 1720 / 1720 ✓ | 1819 / 1819 ✓ | 1935 / 1934 ✓ |
| LCOH year 1 [€/kg] | 4.21 / 4.21 ✓ | 3.58 / 3.58 ✓ | 5.00 / 5.00 ✓ |
| LCOH year 5 [€/kg] (plant age) | 4.42 / 4.42 ✓ | 3.73 / 3.73 ✓ | 5.93 / 5.93 ✓ |
| LCOS tank 350 bar [€/kg] | 0.22 / 0.22 ✓ | 0.22 / 0.22 ✓ | 0.22 / 0.22 ✓ |
| LCOT truck 1 200 km [€/kg] | 6.59 / 6.59 ✓ | 6.59 / 6.59 ✓ | 6.59 / 6.59 ✓ |
| LCOT pipeline 100 km [€/kg] | 33.6 / 33.6 ✓ | 31.8 / 31.8 ✓ | 30.0 / 29.9 ✓ |
| Delivered cost [€/kg] | 9.69 / 9.68 ✓ | 8.87 / 8.87 ✓ | 10.10 / 10.10 ✓ |
| Operational GWP [kg CO₂/kg] | 2.20 / 2.20 ✓ | 2.08 / 2.08 ✓ | 1.96 / 1.96 ✓ |
| Employment [job-years] | 117 / 117 ✓ | 78 / 78 ✓ | 245 / 245 ✓ |
SOEC runs with electrified steam (41 + 7.9 = 48.9 kWh/kg) because the site has no industrial waste heat (§5.4). Year-5 values use the paper's plant-age convention (Table 50); with the stack replaced every ≈2.5 years the physical SOEC year-5 value is lower.
§03
AEL — production
Installed CAPEX
€12.31 M €1026/kW
Paper law C = A·Q^β at 12 MW
OPEX year 1
€5.36 M per year
Electricity €4.73 M + 2.5 % CAPEX + water & labour €0.32 M
Effective SEC
52.0 kWh/kg
Output 1819 t/y
LCOH year 1
€3.58 €/kg
(C·CRF + OPEX)/M, CRF 0.0937
LCOH year 5
€3.73 €/kg
SEC 54.1 kWh/kg after 4 years of fade
Lifecycle LCOH
€3.75 €/kg
D̄rep 1.12, δ̄ 2.5 %
§04
AEL — storage, transport and delivered cost (as specified)
Tank inventory
3.32 t €1.35 M
M = 0.6 × 12 MW × 24 h / SEC; 407 €/kg
LCOS
€0.224 €/kg stored
w = 0.66·ln(350/30) = 1.62 kWh/kg
truck_cgh2 · 1200 km
€6.59 €/kg carried
§5.6 LCOT = 0.35 + 0.52·(1200/100) = 6.59 €/kg; fleet C = 1.43·Z·d/100 = 28.51 M€ (Z = 1.66 t/d)
pipeline · 100 km
€31.82 €/kg carried
Eq. 45: C = (49.7 + 1.755·Z^0.6)·d/100 = 50.93 M€ (Z = 0.55 t/d); O = 2 % C; LCOT = (C·CRF + O)/M
Delivered cost
€8.87 €/kg
LCOH + 0.6·LCOS + 0.3·LCOT₁ + 0.1·LCOT₂ (Eq. 14)
| Channel | Share | Delivered cost | Margin at €6.38/kg |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stored · Compressed tank 350 bar | 60 % | €3.80/kg | €2.58/kg |
| GH₂ tube trailer · 1200 km | 30 % | €10.17/kg | −€3.79/kg |
| Dedicated H₂ pipeline · 100 km | 10 % | €35.40/kg | −€29.02/kg |
§05
AEL — investment decision (§5.10)
Investment I₀
€13.66 M production + tank
Transport legs are service charges
Net operating cash
−€3.25 M per year
Revenue − production, storage and transport cash costs
NPV @ 8 %
−€49.88 M 25 years
Stack replacements discounted at their exact times
IRR
n/a
vs bank 2.25 %
Payback
never (yearly cash flow negative)
Cumulative cash crosses zero
Break-even price
€8.95 €/kg
NPV = 0
Full-cost profit Π
−€4.53 M per year
Σ (p − c_deliv,i)·f_i·M (§5.7)
I₀ left in the bank
€23.83 M after 25 yr
at 2.25 %
§06
Environment, social and scorecard (§5.8–§5.9)
| Metric | PEM | AEL | SOEC |
|---|---|---|---|
| Operational GWP [kg CO₂/kg] | 2.20 | 2.08 | 1.96 |
| Delivered CI incl. transport [kg CO₂/kg] | 3.65 | 3.53 | 3.41 |
| Water [m³/y] | 30,963 | 43,665 | 34,825 |
| Employment [job-years] | 117 | 78 | 245 |
| Q_H2,LHV [MW] | 7.27 | 7.69 | 8.18 |
| Scorecard (transport-optimised, 60/20/10/10) | Profit | Environment | Social | Cost | Weighted |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. AEL | 100.0 | 49.2 | 0.0 | 100.0 | 79.8 |
| 2. PEM | 50.9 | 0.0 | 23.3 | 55.3 | 38.4 |
| 3. SOEC | 0.0 | 100.0 | 100.0 | 0.0 | 30.0 |
Profit is the full-cost annual profit Π of §5.7 for all three technologies.
§07
Existing plant and learning rate (§5.11)
The method applied backwards in time: a 2020 PEM plant re-based to 2026 with Eq. 20, a two-point learning rate, and the enhanced fade of an older plant.
| Quantity | Engine | Paper | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2020 cost on a 2026 basis (2 %/y, Eq. 20) | €1689/kW | €1,689/kW | ✓ |
| Learning exponent b | 0.145 | 0.145 | ✓ |
| Learning rate LR = 1 − 2^(−b) | 9.55 % | 9.5 % | ✓ (paper rounds 9.55 down) |
| PEM SEC after 5 operating years, nominal fade 1.18 %/y | 58.45 kWh/kg (57.0 %) | 58.45 kWh/kg (57.0 %) | ✓ |
| Existing plant, fade × 1.2 = 1.42 %/y | 59.19 kWh/kg (56.3 %) | 59.2 kWh/kg (56.3 %) | ✓ |
Inside the published envelope (7–49 %) but below the typical 18–28 %. Published electrolyser learning rates are about 18–28 % [77]; a two-point estimate cannot separate learning from scale, boundary or location effects.
§08
Benchmarking (Table 58)
Comparison of the case-study outputs with published ranges, classified by evidence role. These support plausibility and internal coherence; they are not a predictive validation for a project.
| Quantity | Engine | Literature | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| Green-H₂ LCOH (cheap RE, bottom-up) | 3.58–5.00 €/kg | 2–5 $/kg | External literature comparison: within range |
| Ordering AEL < PEM < SOEC | PEM 4.21 · AEL 3.58 · SOEC 5.00 | AEL cheapest at scale | Literature-consistent ordering |
| Tank LCOS | 0.22 €/kg | 0.21–0.25 €/kg | Internal consistency check: within band |
| Truck LCOT 1 200 km | 6.59 €/kg | 5–10 $/kg long-haul | External plausibility check: within range |
| Electrolyser learning rate | 9.5 % (two-point, §07) | 7–49 % (18–28 % typ.) | Literature-context comparison |
| Solar green-H₂ GWP | 1.96–2.20 kg/kg | 1–3 kg CO₂/kg | External literature comparison: within range |
§09
What the model does not include
Screening estimate. The results are obtained from harmonised literature equations and may be close to or far from the values of a real project. They are intended as comparative signals for decision support and are not a bankable forecast, so site data and vendor quotes have to be checked before any investment.
| Not included | Review | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Financing structure | §5.10 | No loans, interest, debt/equity split or debt service; NPV and IRR use one project WACC (8 % in the paper). |
| Taxes and depreciation | §5.10 | The DCF is pre-tax; no depreciation schedule. |
| Subsidies and tax credits | §5.13 | Canadian ITC and 45V-type credits are excluded; every profit line would improve with them, so results are conservative here. |
| Residual value and decommissioning | §5.10 | No salvage value or end-of-life cost in the cash flow. |
| Reinvestment beyond stack replacement | §5.10 | Only stack replacements φ·C at their exact dates τ_j are charged. |
| Year-by-year degradation and downtime in the cash flow | §5.10 | Screening DCF with a constant annual operating cash flow; degradation is shown in the year-t and lifecycle LCOH. |
| Ownership of transport assets | §5.10 | Delivery is priced as a purchased service (LCOT per kg); no transport asset enters I₀. |
| Construction period and phased spending | §5.10 | Initial capital is recorded once at t = 0; operation starts in year 1. |
| Hourly dispatch, start–stop cycling and curtailment | §5.3.1 | Operation is described by an annual capacity factor; the fade rate scales with operating hours (§5.3.4). |
| By-product revenue (oxygen, heat sales) | not in the review | Revenue is hydrogen sales only. |
| Regulatory eligibility (EU RFNBO, US 45V, Canadian ITC tiers) | not in the review | Carbon intensity is compared with the literature band of Table 58 (1–3 kg CO₂/kg), not with a legal threshold. |
| Shipping, ammonia and LOHC chains | §5.5 | Benchmark-only — no fitted chain equation. |
| Site-specific engineering data | §5.3.4, §6 | Replace screening rates with vendor quotes, measured voltage-rise/polarisation data and receptor maps for a real project. |